miércoles, 8 de febrero de 2012

A Toast to the Oldest Inhabitant: The Weather of New England by Mark Twain

How does Twain satirize weather forecasters in Mark Twain's story A Toast to the Oldest  Inhabitant: The Weather of New England?

70 comentarios:

  1. He thinks they are "inutile" because it is impossible to predict weather in New England, because of the unpredictable weather change.

    ResponderEliminar
  2. In the story Twain supported a point about the story of the man who collected and exhibited weather.That point was that some weather forecasters are not always true,because weather is always changing. New England can produce diferent types of weather in a short period of time,so that means that weather is unpredictable.(Twain satries forecasters who approximate the next day weather eventhough they make their prediction sound as if they are accurate).

    Andrea Rodriguez Jimenez 10 sabaot

    ResponderEliminar
  3. In the story Twain says that the point of some weather forecasters is not very correct, because in New England the weather is always changing. New England weather change in a very short period of time, so that means that one day you can go out with an unbrella and it will not rain because the weather is unpredictable on New England.

    *Jamie Lugo Martinez 10mo Sabaot :)

    ResponderEliminar
  4. He says that predicting the weather in New England is almost impossible because it changes very often in little time. In a day the climate can change drastically making the people who live there uncertain of simple things like what clothes to put on that day or simpler as if whether take an umbrella or not. We learn that Twain satirize or humiliates them to show the reality of the unpredictable weather in New England.

    ResponderEliminar
  5. Twain talks in the story about how knowing the weather in the area of New England is nearly impossible. He says that theres no way of knowing how the day is going to turn out for sure until you are actually in that day. Twain also satirize the weather forecasters in the story by telling the reader that the climate is in constant change that from being a sunny spring day it can turn into a snowy winter-like one.

    **GUSTAVO COLON 10 ADONAI

    ResponderEliminar
  6. Twain criticez weather forecasters because the weather in New Englad changes so frequently it is almost impossible to predict it. In the story, Mark Twain humiliates weather forescasters letting the reader know that their job there is almost useless.

    -Raisa Diaz
    10 Sabaot

    ResponderEliminar
  7. Twain says that the forecasters are incorrect because the weather is always changing, He says that there is no posible way to know what wheather is comming next. He tells us that the forecasters are basically not helping us because they really don't know the weather.

    ResponderEliminar
  8. Twain says that the weather casters are not real/professional since the weather is always changes. He states that there is no way that the weather can be predicted and thats why he criticizes them.

    - Axviel 10J

    ResponderEliminar
  9. Twain says that the weather forecasters are wrong because predicting New England's weather is impossible because it is always changing.

    Jose Carlos Cordero 10-Adonai

    ResponderEliminar
  10. Twain states that the weather forecasters in New England are not professionals and that they are wrong because they can't predict the weather there since in that area the weather is unpredictable and changes constantly.

    -Lloyd 10J

    ResponderEliminar
  11. Mark Twain criticizes the forecasters because New England´s weather is unpredictable. The weather changes constantly.

    Neida M. Rodriguez, 10 Sabaot

    ResponderEliminar
  12. In this story Mark Twain satirizes weather forecasters because they try to tell the next day's weather and predict it even though they now that in New England the weather is always in constant change and that there will never be a specific type of weather in one day. Twain satirizes this people because even though they try to make their predictions see and sound precise, correct, and clear, New England's weather is impossible to predict because this country can have a big variety of weather in a very short time. Finally he satirizes them because New England has an unstable weather that can change on the blink of an eye and he shows us that someone can try to establish a day's weather but that it will never be specific or totally right.

    Kimberly Roman Diaz (10mo Sabaot)

    ResponderEliminar
  13. In the story twain says that the weather forecasters in New England are incorrect because they can't predict the weather, in New England the weather is always changing (unpredictable),change in a very short period of time so that means that is very difficult to predict it.

    Angelica M. Canabal 10mo Sabaot

    ResponderEliminar
  14. In the story, Twain states that the forecasters are not correct because in New England the weather is always changing. The weater is unpredictable and it can change very fast.

    -Fabiola Raquel Medina Gonzalez
    10 Jireh

    ResponderEliminar
  15. In twain history people try to make predictions certainly correct and clear.In New England's predictions are impossible because the weather change in very little time.Anyone in this place can make predictions corrects, and clears because the weather is very unstable.
    mariela colon 10 (adonai)

    ResponderEliminar
  16. He satirizes the forecasters because they don't know that the weather in New England changes in a short period of time. Its imposible to get the right and perfect prediction of the weather. You can't tell which end of the procession is going to move first you can only tell that there will be plenty of weather.

    Blanca Paola Atiles
    10mo Adonai

    ResponderEliminar
  17. Twain satirize weather forecasters because he says that they think they can control the weather. Weather forecasters "predict" the weather but really it is imposible to predict it and New England can produce every type of weather in a short period of time.

    -Charlene De Jesús
    -10mo Sabaot

    ResponderEliminar
  18. Twain satirizes the forecasters because they try to predict the weather in New England,knowing that it changes so fast.It is impossible to predict what will happen because weather is very unsatable.
    Kimberly Vazquez Arocho 10-sabaot<3

    ResponderEliminar
  19. Twain satirize the weather forecasters because New Englang's weather changes all the time and he thinks that the job of the weather forecasters is almost useless since the weather is unpredictable in that place.

    Omayra Ivelisse Velez Cruz 10-Adonai

    ResponderEliminar
  20. Este comentario ha sido eliminado por el autor.

    ResponderEliminar
  21. He satirizes the weather forcasters because they try to find something that is almost impossible because the weather in new England is always changing and unpredictable.

    Mariana Ivelisse Velez Cruz 10-Adonai

    ResponderEliminar
  22. the weather in New England was constantly changing and the forecasters were doing nothing and his work was not usefull. the work was nothing because the weather was changing very rapidly all time

    ResponderEliminar
  23. In the story Twain its says that some weather forecasters are not always true, in New England the weather is always changing,they can't predict exactly the weather as is going to be.

    Mariel Elisa

    ResponderEliminar
  24. Twain thinks that the meteorologist are useless because they weren't doing anything. It is impossible to predict weather in New England because of the unpredictable weather change.


    Jonathan velazquez

    ResponderEliminar
  25. Twain satirizes the forecasters because they want to tell how the weather will be and it is wrong. It is wrong because they know that it can change in a short time or quickly and the weather is in a continuous change.

    *cecilia haydemar

    ResponderEliminar
  26. In the story Twain tells us that it is almost impossible to predict the weather in New England because it is constantly changing. It'a a hard job for the forecasters because even if they predict the weather right one day, it can change that very same day into the complete opposite making them lose their credibility.


    ** GABRIEL MARTINEZ 10 JIREH

    ResponderEliminar
  27. In the story Twain says that is kind of useless the work of a forecasters because the weather in New England is always changing, very unpredictable and they could say that it was going to rain but in a short period of time that weather would be different.

    Andrea Paola
    10Adonai

    ResponderEliminar
  28. Twain tells us that predicting the weather of New England is impossible because it changes all the time.You can never know how the day is gong to turn out. He said that the forecasters are not helping people because the weather of New England is unpredictable.

    Daniella Dorta 10 Adonai

    ResponderEliminar
  29. Este comentario ha sido eliminado por el autor.

    ResponderEliminar
  30. Twain says that predicting the weather on New England is not possible because it changes very frequently. They can never know how the day is going to be. He said that the forecasters are not really helping the people because the weather in New England can expected, but it is not imminent.

    ResponderEliminar
  31. Twain says al the time that the weather in New England is not possible to predict because it changes all the time. Because of this changes people can't make plans because of the continuosly changing weather. The unpredictible weather, the forecartes can't help the people know the precise weather

    ResponderEliminar
  32. In the essay, Twain says that predicting the weather in New England is almost impossible because it changes very often. Some days it could be raining, the other day snowing it change really fast. And sometimes People have to change there plans because of of the changing of the weather.

    ResponderEliminar
  33. In the story we see that New England's weather is very unpredictable. It changes constantly making it hard for the people living there to make plans. That's why he criticizes forecasters, because the weather is always changing and almost impossible for them to tell how it is going to be.
    ~ Paola A. Rivera :) 10mo J

    ResponderEliminar
  34. New England's weather changes so much that the forecoster can't predict the weather. The changing weather is very varying that people can't plan their day. Even says that if you want to see all changes in weather you don't have to go around the world; just go to New England and you will see everything.
    Janelis Perez 10 Adonai

    ResponderEliminar
  35. The author satirizes the weather forecasters because of the unpredicatable weather in NewEngland. He views their jobs as worthless and useless. Weather forecasters are important to people in many fields becuase they are used to protect life and properties, in addition, they help people make plans daily. Throughout the story, England is a place that you cannot tell if sunshine, rain, snow, fog, and wind will surprise people.

    Karla M. Pagán Santiago
    10-Adonai

    ResponderEliminar
  36. Twain satirizes the weathermen because he views there job as useless. Also, it annoys him when they say that the weather will be something and they state it as a fact, when you can't really tell what it will be. The weather is impossible to predict in New England, and he thinks it's foolish that anyone would try to guess it.

    Arnaldo Colón; Decimo Sabaot

    ResponderEliminar
  37. In the story "A toast to the oldest inhabition" Twain satirize the weather foracasters because they have a job that is not needed in New England because the weather is always changing and no matter what they said about the weather during the day, it is going to change and the foracaster would be disappointed and they would lost credibility.

    Natalia R. Cid-10Adonai

    ResponderEliminar
  38. Twain says that the forecasters in New England are incorrect because the weather is always changing , and he states that there is no way that the weather can be predicted and thats why he criticizes them.

    jennifer cortes
    10 sabaot

    ResponderEliminar
  39. Twain criticizes the forecasters in New England , because the weather in New England is unpredictable.There are weather changes constantly.

    *Christopher O. Rojas
    10 sabaot

    ResponderEliminar
  40. In the story "A toast to the oldest inhabition", Twain satirizes the weathermen. He compare their jobs as useless. In New England, predictions are impossible because the weather change all the time and it is difficult to predict it.

    Jelismarie De Jesus Trujillo
    10mo Adonai (:

    ResponderEliminar
  41. In the story "The weather of New England" Mark Twain satirizes the weathermen forecaster because the weather of New England is changing every time. For example you can leave your umbrella in the house and rain can appear over you in short time later. He add humor in his essay.

    Luis Soto 10 sabaot.

    ResponderEliminar
  42. Twain satirizes the weathermen becouse for him this job is not useless. The weather in New England change a lot and is impossible to predict it . For Twain is funny to when they predict something and later the weater change.
    10 sabaot roberto

    ResponderEliminar
  43. For Twain trying to predict New England´s weather doesn´t makes any sence because it changes constantly. That´s why he satirizes the forecaster.

    ResponderEliminar
  44. Twain satirize weather forecasters because he knows how useless they are in New England. He shows that there is impossible to predict weather because of its changes. You never know if you go out on a sunny day and when you come back home youre going to be wet because of the rain. Weather forecasters try to predict the unpredictable, N.E's weather is always changing.

    Valeria S. Gonzalez ---- 10 Sabaot

    ResponderEliminar
  45. Twain satirize weather forecasters because he thinks they are useless because in New England it is impossible to predict the weather because it is always changing. To Mark Twain the forecasters annoys him because when they say that the weather will be one way it ends up being the opposite or not the way they announce to the people because you can't really tell what it will be.

    Fiama Morales.. 10mo Jireh

    ResponderEliminar
  46. Twain thinks that the weather forecasters are usless and unproffesionals in new England because the weather in that area change drastically and they cant predict exactly the weather.

    ResponderEliminar
  47. In the story Mark twain satirizes the weather forecasts because people try to make a prediction of the weather and it is impossible to make a correct prediction because the weather of New England is always changing.

    Lerianis Curbelo Vega 10-Sabaot

    ResponderEliminar
  48. Twain informs us about weather because the weather in New Englad changes so frequently it is almost impossible to predict it. It talks about how the weather constantly changes all of a sudden and there's no way to predict it , its almost impossible

    Andrea Saldana
    10 Sabaot

    ResponderEliminar
  49. He says it is useless to perdict the weather beacuse of its sudden changes

    ResponderEliminar
  50. The weather in New England is very unpredictable and meteorologists never be able to report the correct weather that is going to be during the day in New England.

    ResponderEliminar
  51. The weather is always unpredictable , and Twain did't think weatherment should try to guess.

    ResponderEliminar
  52. Twain says that in New England the weather is unpredictable, this means that the weather isn't to easy to predict.
    -Emily! ;)

    ResponderEliminar
  53. He didnt understand the weathermens reason for predicting the weather

    ResponderEliminar
  54. Twain expresses that the weather iN New England is so unpredictable to meterologist can never predict an accurate forcast since the weather is alwayz changing, making a suppostly sunny day a pouring day

    Melanie Cubano
    10 Jireh

    ResponderEliminar
  55. Twain's point of view of the weather is that it may not be decifered by anyone Because Englands weather is unpredictible ... conditions may change in a short period of time, so forecasts and weather-men are useless.

    Nicole Cruz / 10 Jireh

    ResponderEliminar
  56. Twain expresses that the weather in new england is so unpredictable because it change frequently.

    Gabriel Alejandro Acevedo :)
    10 jireh

    ResponderEliminar
  57. Twain tells us that predicting the weather of New England is impossible because it change frequently. He said that the forecasters may be are not helping people too much because the weather is unpredictable.

    Tatiana Toro <3
    10 jireh

    ResponderEliminar
  58. Twain's expression about the weather in New England is that it changes so frequently it is almost impossible to predict.




    Grashka Torres...
    10 Jireh

    ResponderEliminar
  59. In the story Twain says that the point of some weather forecasters is not very correct. New England weather change in a very short period of time, so that means that one day you can go out with an umbrella and it will not rain, because the weather is unpredictable on New England.

    Jared Zayas Torres
    10mo Adonai

    ResponderEliminar
  60. This story is about the climate of New England. trying to predict but can not because all the time is changing

    ResponderEliminar
  61. Mark Twain talks about New England climate. That its so unpredictable because always is changing.

    ResponderEliminar
  62. Twain states that the job is quite useless because the weather is so unpredictable and is constantly changing that they can't state the forecast for sure.

    ResponderEliminar
  63. Mark Twain states that weather forecasters in New England are quite meaningless. Since the weather is constantly changing, their job really is unnecessary because they cannot predict the weather with a high level of certainty.

    ResponderEliminar
  64. Both stories have a positive message and gives you a good way off viewing things in the story " The Empty Dance Shoes" gives you a funny twist and uses good examples and "The Twist" tells you that even if you dont remember things in the past your still good and theres no problem with that your human.

    gabriela rios cruz
    10 adonai

    ResponderEliminar
  65. The poems transmit the messege by metaphors. They tell us about their childhood memories. The messege that they transmit is positive. They have little memories of their childhood but is still important for them.

    -Amy :P!
    10 Adonai

    ResponderEliminar
  66. Twain has a strong feeling against these weather forecasters because weather in England is so unpredictable. He feels there is no use to this job considering the weather is always in such constant change.

    ResponderEliminar
  67. Twain says that in New England the weather is unpredictable because always changes.We can learn that Twain humiliates them to show the reality of the unpredictable weather in New England.

    Astrid C. Pérez Reyes
    10 Jireh

    ResponderEliminar
  68. Twain satirizes the weathermen because he views there job as useless. Also, it annoys him when they say that the weather will be something and they state it as a fact, when you can't really tell what it will be. The weather is impossible to predict in New England and in the world, so he thinks that it's foolish that anyone would try to guess it. Andre julian marrero 10 adonai

    ResponderEliminar
  69. Twain says that in New England the weather is unpredictable because it always changes. The weather is impossible to predict. And twain is saying that his job is usefull because the weather always change and they cannot predict the weather well.

    ResponderEliminar
  70. He practically tells us that the weather forecasters are useless because there is no way you can predict New England weather.

    ResponderEliminar